Dust extraction for a small shop

Hi all,

I am setting my workshop up in a one car garage and space is limited. I will be running a Table saw, bandsaw, mitre saw, disk sander and router table and eventually a drum sander and jointer.

I picked up 2nd hand 2HP economy extractor http://ift.tt/1M3y1Hr but am now concerned that I don't have the room.

I considered buying one of these small Scheppach units and dedicating one to the tablesaw, one to the bandsaw and one to the router table http://ift.tt/1li5pBu but from what I've read on here most people say it will be useless.

I've also been looking at the Clear Vue mini system mounted to either the Scheppach or my Ryobi shopvac http://ift.tt/1li5pBw

So my question is

What will give me the best dust extraction?

- The Clearvue mini attached to a Scheppach or Ryobi shopvac
OR
- The Carbatec 2HP dust collector unit?

Am I better to suck it up and find room for the 2HP Carbatec unit?

Also note that this all needs to be situated inside the garage, I have no room to put any of this outside.


Thanks all.

Daz.

Dust extraction for a small shop